Going to ask this directly since the indirect route has been useless: How are different dating apps rated for user safety?
From what I've seen, what I've found through normal research is basically useless for making an actual decision, at least that has been the pattern. Personally, the top-ranked content is all affiliate-driven. As far as I can tell, the app store reviews are heavily managed. Reddit threads are better but still often dominated by a handful of power users with specific experiences that may not generalize, though I would not bet the house on it.
For what it's worth, community forums like this one tend to have more actual diversity of experience, which is exactly what I need, for whatever that is worth. Personally, not one definitive answer — a range of experiences that helps me calibrate my own expectations going in, at least in my experience.
From what I've seen, thanks in advance for anything real, depending on which app you are on. Anecdotally, happy to share back once I've spent more time testing.